Prototyping without Assets

I think one of the main benefits to prototyping without assets is that it encourages you not to get bogged down with the audio and visual polish of your game, and instead encourages you to focus on what’s absolutely essential. In particular, it tends to place the emphasis on the core mechanics and interactions of your player:

  • Is this game functional?

Fundamentally, is the game’s core experience strong enough that all it should really need is some refining and fleshing out in order to reach the desired end product and end experience for the user? Using placeholder assets, or event just using primitives (squares, cubes, cylinders, etc.) allow us to prototype often and rapidly.

‘White boxing’ is a particularly popular industry practice for prototyping levels

This can save independent developers a lot of time, and on larger-scale teams they can also save money that could’ve been wasted if an art team developed a lot of good-looking assets for a game or level that ultimately needed to be abandoned or heavily revised.

Doing this tends to be critical in achieving an agile and more iterative development process. I’m also reminded of the distinction a teacher of mine brought my attention to — between ‘visual fidelity’ and ‘functional fidelity’ in prototypes:

  • Visual fidelity. A prototype might have high visual fidelity if you spend a lot of time developing the aesthetics to it, but might have fairly low functional fidelity. It might not be interactive at this stage, and might be more of a tech demo of sorts to give a suggestion of what the end product might, literally, look like.

Ultimately it’s generally going to be a lot more feasible and a lot less time consuming to aim at functional fidelity over visual fidelity, but I can appreciate that in some cases the visuals/aesthetics are really going to be what make the experience come alive. For instance, the mechanics and interactions of Gris might not win you over or even define the game, but its art direction most likely will. I do think it’s important to note possible exceptions like these, but at the same time when it comes to the work we primarily do as game developers and programmers our emphasis will most likely fall onto interactions, behaviours, and mechanics.



Game Developer | Game Design and Literature Graduate

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store